What happens to Bernie and our political revolution if Hillary is elected?
Bernie will be a minor player in the Senate during a Hillary Clinton administration. Bernie will continue organizing the political revolution, but will be in Clinton’s shadow for the duration of her tenure in office.
Quite a different scenario will emerge if Hillary is defeated by Donald Trump. Bernie’s role in the party and as the leader of its progressive wing will be profoundly more important.
Bernie will be the new leader of the party. His firebrand political organizing will be geared to winning the midterm elections in 2018 and in building the progressive control of the party toward the 2020 elections. The political revolution will be alive and well. And Bernie will be in charge.
Neither Trump nor Hillary will be able to get any meaningful or controversial legislation through the divided Congress. The Republicans will continue to hold the House and the Democrats will retake control of the Senate. Whomever is president will be considered a failure and will be very unpopular heading into the 2018 and 2020 elections.
And that fact is critical, because winning control of statehouses in 2018 and 2020 is the key to control of the House of Representatives through the year 2030.
Congressional districts are reapportioned every ten years, after the taking of the US Census. In 2010 the Republicans successfully won enough statehouses to control reapportionment. Through a process known as gerrymandering, they stacked the deck in their favor, crafting a majority of safe districts for Republicans across the country. The result has been that Republicans have more Members of Congress even though Republicans received fewer total votes than did Democrats.
In 2020 reapportionment will occur again, following the Census. If Democrats do not win back a majority of statehouses, the Republicans will be able to repeat in 2020 what they did in 2010: control the House for another ten years.
If Hillary is elected in 2016, Democrats can kiss the House goodbye until 2030.
Consider: She will be a failed unpopular president because of gridlock in Washington. That gridlock will be even more pronounced than Obama has been experiencing. Her current disapproval ratings will look positively benign compared to the levels to which they will dive once in office.
Even with the popular incumbent president Barack Obama in 2014, Democrats were unable to win the House. Under Hillary in 2018 we will do much worse. Same with the 2020 campaign, especially if Hillary is seeking re-election. It will be a Republican landslide.
The exact opposite result will occur if Donald Trump is elected in 2016. He, too, would accomplish nothing, and would be even more unpopular than he is currently.
Democrats would sweep in 2018 and in 2020. We would control reapportionment and control the House through 2030.
And most importantly, it would be accomplished under Bernie’s leadership with the revolution proceeding ahead at full speed. Progressives at all levels of government will be elected because of Bernie. Millennials will grow into positions of authority and influence in government, business, and society.
America will fundamentally change!
Defeating Hillary is key to achieving the goal. We need to remove her from control of the party and we need to prevent her from leading the party into oblivion in 2018 and 2020.
The way to defeat Hillary is to vote for Donald Trump in those swing states where he has the potential of defeating her. In states that are solidly red or blue, progressives should support Jill Stein of the Greens. Growing the Green party should be a primary goal of progressives.
For those with reservations about voting for a neocon warmonger who supports military interventionism, regime change, and the bombing of civilians, Trump is a welcome respite. Aside from holding positions significantly more progressive than Hillary on those issues, he is also more progressive on trade, corporate control of government, universal healthcare, and the revolving door between government and industry.
But Trump’s actual positions are irrelevant,
He will not be able to implement any controversial proposals, as he will face the same divided Congress that Hillary would face. The Republicans controlling the House, the Democrats controlling the Senate.
From the outset of his campaign Bernie recognized he would have to endorse Hillary. To be assured of a place at the table, Bernie feels he must put on the face of a loyal Democrat. It is probably killing him! But Bernie is taking the long view here. He is looking to the next several election cycles, fully aware that the old guard is on it’s last legs. The Millennials are coming! The entire Democratic party is changing before our eyes. And the next Democratic nominee, after Hillary, will be a Sanders progressive.
Bernie believes it would be easier to change the party into a democratic socialist party than it would be to grow the Greens into national contention. He knows that a significant number of rank-and-file Democrats mindlessly vote for the party. And he knows he must be perceived as having helped rather than hurt Hillary to avoid the establishment blaming Bernie if she loses. The best thing that could happen would be, of course, that Hillary is defeated, leaving Bernie and his progressives the major force in the party. But he can never admit as much.
The only weapon that the Democratic establishment can wield against the progressive left is that Bernie helped to defeat Hillary. And they only get to play that card if Hillary loses. But if Bernie has endorsed her and stumps for her, they have nothing to hold against Bernie.
As president, Hillary will be able to stack the party leadership as Obama did. Progressives will be frozen out and marginalized. Wall Street Democrats will have even more influence than they had under Obama. Bernie’s revolution will play out in Democratic primaries at the local level.
Policies that Bernie has been fighting will be implemented, Hillary will embrace the TPP, escalate international tensions with Russia, Iran, and China. She will support the TTIP, the next disastrous trade deal with Europe. Medicare for all will be a distant dream again.
The value of a Trump presidency is that it will not be a Hillary Clinton presidency,
We will have kicked the Wall Street Democrats to the curb.
The irony is that Donald Trump will help Bernie Sanders’ political revolution, even though unintentionally.
5 thoughts on “Vote Trump if you are in a Swing State. Vote Jill Everywhere Else!”
You missed a bet By not recognized the popularity of Jill Stein and it’s growing. That would help understand what a green party victory would look like.
Think outside the box — there are more than more than two parties
Voting is People Power that Kicks Corporate America out of Congress VoterNinja.com
Much as I would love to see Jill Stein in the White House, it is an impossible dream. She is polling less than 5% nationally, and is even trailing the Libertarian Johnson who is roughly doubling Stein’s numbers. In order to win, Stein would have to reach 270 electoral votes, an outright majority, to avoid the contest going to the House of Representatives. With a little more than two months to go, there is not a single state in which Stein is leading, let alone commanding a majority of voters.
I would rather vote for Jill Stein in a swing state.
On Aug 25, 2016 8:36 AM, “Armory of the Revolution” wrote:
> Roland Vincent posted: ” What happens to Bernie and our political > revolution if Hillary is elected? Bernie will be a minor player in the > Senate during a Hillary Clinton administration. Bernie will continue > organizing the political revolution, but will be in Clinton’s shad” >
Depends on what you are trying to accomplish. It also presumes that swing states are in play for the Greens, which I do not believe is remotely possible.
Reblogged this on Species and Class.